Browning Citori 725 Sporting vs. Weatherby Orion Sporting: Which Over-Under Shotgun Wins?

Check out the original YouTube video here

A Day at the Range

It’s not every day you get to put two well-known over-under shotguns head-to-head. At the gun club, we brought out two crowd favorites: the Browning Citori 725 Sporting and the Weatherby Orion Sporting.

Both are respected in the clay shooting world, but they target different audiences — the Orion being known as an affordable entry-level gun, while the Citori 725 sits comfortably in the mid-range premium category.

To keep things fair, we shot 50 sporting clays, switching guns halfway through. The goal: find out how these two classics stack up in performance, comfort, and value.

Gun Specs and Setup

Weatherby Orion (2024):

• 12 gauge

• 30-inch ported barrels with vent rib

• Modified choke (top) and improved cylinder (bottom)

• Adjustable comb for rise and cast

• 14.5″ length of pull

• Weight: 7.5 lbs

• Today's Price: ~$1,100

  
  

Browning Citori 725 Sporting (2012):

• 12 gauge

• 30-inch ported barrels with vent rib, mid-bead, and end bead

• Same choke setup: modified (top) and improved cylinder (bottom)

• Adjustable comb

• 14.75″ length of pull

• Weight: 8 lbs 1 oz

• Today's Price: ~$3,300 (Roughly triple the Orion’s price)

  
  

Despite the difference in cost, both guns share a surprising number of similarities — adjustable combs, barrel length, porting, and overall configuration. The biggest immediate differences are the Citori’s extra half-pound of weight and its mid-bead sight, which the Orion lacks.

Performance and Shooting Results

Out on the course, both guns performed smoothly.

• Patrick (shooting the Orion first) scored 45/50, missing only three with the Orion and two with the Citori.

• Scott shot 38/50, splitting misses evenly between the two guns.

  
  

The results showed that both shotguns are capable performers. Despite the large price gap, there was virtually no difference in accuracy or felt recoil between the two.

Fit, Feel, and Handling

After switching guns mid-round, both shooters noticed subtle differences in ergonomics.

• The Citori’s receiver sits slightly closer to the shooter’s face, due to a shorter trigger-to-breech measurement (2.5″ vs. 3″ on the Orion).

• The Orion’s lighter weight did not affect follow-through or control.

• Both guns delivered nearly identical recoil, which is impressive considering the Orion’s lower mass.

Trigger feel was another point of interest. The Orion’s trigger blade is thinner and allowed for more natural finger placement, while the Citori offered a more refined overall feel and user-replaceable triggers for customization.

Build Quality and Durability

When it comes to craftsmanship, the Browning Citori 725 Sporting naturally edges ahead. Its fit, finish, and overall build feel more refined. It’s the kind of gun that could easily last a lifetime of shooting.

That said, the Weatherby Orion proved reliable as well. With over a thousand rounds through it, it’s still running flawlessly. While it may not carry the same premium polish, it certainly delivers where it counts — consistent performance and dependability.

Price and Value

This is where things get interesting. The Browning Citori costs roughly three times as much as the Weatherby Orion, yet offers very similar performance in most aspects.

If your goal is maximum value, the Orion clearly wins. For a third of the price, you get nearly all the same features, an adjustable comb, and excellent real-world shooting results. That leaves extra cash for ammo, range time, and clays — which will improve your shooting more than gear ever could.

However, if you appreciate fine craftsmanship, longevity, and the prestige that comes with owning a Browning, the Citori 725 Sporting still holds its ground as a beautifully built firearm.

Final Verdict

Category	Winner	Why
Performance	Tie	Nearly identical scores and recoil
Build Quality	Browning Citori 725	Superior materials and fit
Value for Money	Weatherby Orion	Delivers 90% of the performance for 30% of the price
Recoil & Comfort	Tie	Both shotguns shoot soft and smooth
Ergonomics	Slight Edge: Citori	Closer receiver and mid-bead for refined handling

In the end, the Browning Citori 725 Sporting is the higher-end shotgun with finer craftsmanship, while the Weatherby Orion offers unbeatable value for the everyday shooter.

If your goal is to get more practice, more rounds, and more fun out of your investment, the Orion might just be the smarter buy. But if you’re after legacy, precision, and a shotgun that will last generations — the Citori still earns its premium status.

Your Turn

Have you shot either the Weatherby Orion or the Browning Citori 725 Sporting? Share your experience in the comments — which one do you prefer and why?

And as always, subscribe to Average Joe’s Armory for more head-to-head gun reviews, range tests, and honest discussions from shooters who love what they do.

We compare the Browning Citori 725 Sporting and Weatherby Orion over-under shotguns in a side-by-side sporting clays test. Discover key differences in performance, feel, value, and why one may be the best buy for you.

Browning Citori 725, Weatherby Orion, Over-Under Shotgun Review, Sporting Clays, Shotgun Comparison, Firearms Review, Trap and Skeet, Browning vs Weatherby, Average Joe’s Armory